
By B
Grade:B
Starting Over, in case you didn’t know, is the most revolutionary television program of all times. This brilliant soap-opera-meets-reality-show-meets-Dr. Phil is taking the tired “seven strangers picked to live in an apartment” formula to thrilling new heights of banality, by being on Every Fucking Day. And I am not talking a measly thirty minutes here. No, you can spend five whole hours per week following the life struggles of this constantly rotating armada of completely hopeless women. While Survivor, much as I love it, never seems to linger long enough on the castaways’ petty bickering over rice and coconuts, Starting Over has all the time in the world to devote to the most prosaic of conflicts, such as, Is Josie a Bad Mother For Letting Baby Chloe Chew on a Biscuit and Will or Will Not Deborah (pronounced, duh-BORE-uh) Eat With the Group? In comparison to MTV’s venerable THE REAL WORLD, which is also produced by the reality pioneers of Bunim/Murray, and which is forced to edit five months of exploits into a few barely-there SweeTarts of catfighting and navel-gazing, Starting Over is downright epic. I swear it is Mary-Ellis (RIP) and John’s Iliad, or their Gravity’s Rainbow, or their Remembrance of Things Past. And believe me, I would not put it past them to spend a whole episode on the topic of Precisely How Delicious and Delicate is Towanda’s Little French Cookie?
Here is the concept behind the program: They take a bunch of middle-aged ladies, each dysfunctional in her own way, and come up with a diagnosis for each one. For instance: Maureen smelled bad and smoked too much. Nyanza was your token lunatic black lady, though she later ceded that mantle to Kimberlyn and, now, Deborah. (See pronunciation key above.) Christine 1 was extremely fat. Cassie was a total idiot. Et cetera. After each woman’s problem is pinpointed, it is reworded into a euphemistic goal, appropriately cloaked in jargonistic therapy-speak. In this way, Christine 1’s goal became, RECLAIM MY WOMANHOOD. (Note: ew ew ew!) Maureen’s became, BECOME A STAND-UP COMIC.
Finally, they place the women in an over-the-top REAL WORLD STYLE MANSION, except with a twist of lady and another twist of inspirational. Think lots of paintings of leaping, stylized rainbow ladies, all bosomy and uplifting. YES! Then they bicker a lot, hug, menstruate incessantly, and, receive therapy from celebrity “Life Coach” IYANLA VANZANT. This is the kind of therapy that is mostly concerned with humiliating stunts and camera-ready activities, such as forcing the women to take embarrassing, nude, boudoir photos, so that they can “love their bodies” or to don skimpy teddies and purple feather boas to dance around on the countertops and “celebrate sexuality.” When the producers are sick of them, they are deemed "cured" and graduate. It all culminates in receiving The Most Precious Gift, which is usually a make-over and a trip to the spa.
The first season of Starting Over was a fabulously unpredictable car-wreck—no one seemed to know what was going on—especially the producers— which made for a refreshing change of pace from the usual, predigested reality crap, even if sometimes it seemed like there was no story at all. The new series has been airing for a few weeks now, but it seems a little… professional for my taste. Frankly, these women are just not as wretched as they were before. JOSIE looks almost (almost) pretty, now that she has popped out that enormous, bald child, and TONI BRAXTON’S PRACTICALLY-AS-BEAUTIFUL SISTER is trying to “learn to forgive.” Two of the new women, Jennifer and Kim, do not seem to have any discernible problems besides looking like newscasters. But I do not watch Starting Over to see halfway attractive people. I watch it to see the miserable, the destitute, and the terminally hideous. Please, give me back THERESA, with her disfigured face and her boyfriend-stealing ways. Give me the fat Mormon PJ, and her constantly swollen glands. And Josie, could you please do us all a favor and get knocked up again by one of a possible three or four trailer-dwelling suitors? I miss the old Starting Over. Deborah was the last beacon of utter disaster, and she stalked off in an inexplicable huff on today’s episode, presumably never to return.
In the spirit of being helpful, I would like to nominate my eleventh grade history teacher, Miss A Taylor as a prime candidate to rehabilitate the show’s hopelessness quotient. Trust me, Bunim/Murray-- with her gimlet eyes and quadruple boob syndrome, her irrational confusion over the most elementary of geographical facts (east versus west, north versus south, and so on) and her tendency toward hysterical, inscrutable crying jags, this woman would put even the most hardcore of the Starting Over HARD LUCK CASES to shame. I smell a ratings bonanza!
Unfortunately, the sheer volume of Starting Over-age makes the program a little daunting to keep up with, especially for people who are not able, for whatever reason, to be parked in front of the television every weekday at noon. That is a fine hour for the show’s target demographic of sad, unemployed, vacuuming wenches, but we bon vivants and gentlemen of leisure need our beauty sleep. I simply cannot be up that early, at least not more than once a week. And it is important to keep up, because as each rehabilitated lady graduates the program, she is replaced by another who is equally pathetic—but in a different way. Yes, it is heartening to know that there is an unending supply of desperate housewives eager to have their weight problems, vaginal maladies, and emotional hangups laid bare in front of the camera, but you have to be careful, because if you miss a week of programming, you will turn on the television to find all your favorite characters replaced by unfamiliar doppelgangers. Imagine my horror on the terrible day when I tuned in to discover that NYANZA AND MAUREEN had disappeared, never—okay, rarely—to be seen again. (The one exception is gorgon-faced “style expert” ANDIE, who never misses an opportunity to make a reappearance.) The solution to the problem, of course, is to use your boyfriend’s TiVo to stay current, but BEWARE-- he will get very mad at you if you cause his precious Olympics to be erased by clogging the memory up with your ladyish nonsense.
But those are quibbles anyway. The genius behind Starting Over that it combines the addictive relentlessness of a daytime soap opera, the sexy, hothouse atmosphere of THE REAL WORLD and the borderline pornographic sob-story luridness of Queen For a Day. I am confident that with a few minor adjustments, it will be right back up to the high standard set by season 1. A little less polish and a little more NYANZA, please!!!